submission from rebvodka-closet-admirers:
love your blog! dont know why i never found it before. i was talking with someone about this before as i re-read No Easy Answers the other day, and I was thinking…given the fact that Eric used to say that Brooks Brown used to always lie to impress others (even BB admitted it)…do you think he could of possibly made up the whole “brooks i like you now” conversation?? just curious about your opinion, but he has been pretty consistent with his story, and it does add up, but maybe eric didnt even say anything to him, and brooks was just outside and heard gunshots?? either way i was just curious haha.
—————–
Thank you! I think you never found it before because I tend to go a little unnoticed and post so irregularly that people only find me when I’ve made a new post or am referred to directly by another blog. 😉 Glad to hear you enjoy it, though!
Eric did say that Brooks lied a lot to impress others or to just sound more interesting or whatever, which seems to have been one of Eric’s pet peeves about Brooks. The tall tales Brooks told certainly got on Eric’s nerves. 😉 Brooks admits to this, too, in later years especially, and I believe he said something along the lines of that kind of lying just being something kids do sometimes.
Brooks has been consistent about that “I like you now”-story, yes. He told police as much from the start, given his witness statements to them, and it’s been a very consistent story from day one onward. The surrounding statements he makes in his witness account about the gym bags Eric carried with him or was moving into the front seat of the car are what make me believe he’s telling the truth, as those bags contained the bombs, and it’s also noteworthy that Brooks mentions Eric didn’t park in his usual space. He definitely encountered Eric that day.
Knowing Brooks’s outgoing nature and inability to keep his mouth shut, he would likely have said something to Eric in that encounter. He said that he commented to Eric about Eric missing the test they had earlier that day, which seems like exactly the kind of exchange Brooks would start in on. Eric responded to that with that weird kind of quiet intensity that I think Brooks knew spelled trouble. Brooks has mentioned since that Eric could have these moodswings and went “hot or cold” at the blink of an eye. Given their past fights, it seems really likely to me that Brooks could predict when to leave Eric alone. He walked away from Eric on that day knowing something was off, but not registering what was going on until he heard the pops of the gunshots. And he knew, immediately, that it was Eric.. if they hadn’t had that odd encounter just before, I don’t think his thoughts would’ve gone to Eric straight off the bat.
And maybe the actual exchange was a little different from how Brooks told it, given how Brooks lied about a lot of things, but I also think of Eric’s long-standing appreciation for irony that makes the “I like you now, get outta here, go home”-statement so much more likely to have been said exactly the way Brooks reported it. Here was this guy Eric had hated and threatened and disliked on principle, standing right in front of him on the day everyone was going to die.. and Eric couldn’t lift a finger to harm Brooks, because he was running late himself and landed himself in a chaotic sense of organisation trying to get it all done in time. Brooks’s timing was what saved him: a few minutes later, and that exchange might’ve seen a different ending. I think that Eric was appreciative of the irony of this – it seems like the sort of thing he would get really amused by, which Brooks essentially confirms by saying Eric was almost chuckling to himself when he told Brooks to “go home”.